Every year, my partner Don and I give up something for Lent, even though neither of us is particularly religious. Two years ago, it was plastic. (Try grocery shopping without buying anything shrouded in the stuff—it's not easy.) This year, I floated an unorthodox idea. Why don't we take the Food Stamp Challenge, only we'll limit ourselves to organic ingredients?
I'll admit that I came up with this challenge in part because I'm annoyed by the common perception that organic food is somehow "elitist." Most recently, this meme was perpetuated by New York Times
contributor Roger Cohen. (If you really want to know what I think of his line of thought, see here.)
The notion that only well-heeled Whole Foods shoppers care about organic food is misguided. As I've written about food justice organizations and urban farming projects over the past few years, I've met plenty of low-income people who go out of their way to find food that hasn't been doused in pesticides. (What's really elitist is the assumption that they wouldn't want healthy food, too.) Many low-income people find ways to afford it—be it growing veggies in a backyard garden, combing through items at the food bank, shopping at
Walmart, or using food stamps at farmers' markets. If you don't believe me, hear this: SNAP sales at farmers' markets increased 42% from 2011 to 2012. (In total, SNAP recipients spent $16,598,255 at farmers' markets in 2012.)
Hundreds of Clevelanders rely on this community garden for food
That's not to say that organic food is cheap. In fact, as you probably know, it's typically more expensive than conventionally grown/raised food—especially when it comes to meat and dairy. (Though that's changing as demand for organic food increases and economies of scale reduce the cost of production.) So I was really curious: Could my family of three survive on a food stamp budget buying nothing but organic food?
When I moved to Oregon three years ago, I was living alone and making so little as a freelance writer that I qualified for the maximum food stamp allotment: $200 a month. Currently, the maximum allowance for SNAP benefits (the technical term for food stamps) in Oregon for a family of three is $526. That's $131.50 a week for groceries. That doesn't sound too bad until you break it down per meal: $6.25 total, or $2 per person. (Though most people who do the SNAP challenge limit themselves to the average food stamp benefit in their state, we chose to limit ourselves to the maximum allotment. I'll explain why in a later post.)
Don and I are both frugal by nature—and we both know how to cook—but I worry: Does this mean six weeks of organic rice and beans?
Here are our ground rules:
• Because we abhor waste, we're allowing ourselves to use up whatever was already in our cupboard (or fridge) before this Challenge began—whether it's organic or not. Fortunately, we typically buy 95% organic food anyway. But this does give us an unfair advantage—we already have olive oil, spices, sour cream, almond butter, and random hunks of cheese. We also have some basic staples like flour, lentils, and rice. That said, we're doing this Challenge for six weeks, so we'll need to replace most if not all of these with our lower budget.
• We will always buy USDA certified organic unless the food meets our conditions for "beyond organic." For example, the raw milk we buy from a dairy down in Champoeg is not certified organic because our dairy farmer has only three cows and it wouldn't be worth it for her to go through the organic certification process. However, we've visited the farm on several occasions and know "our" cows graze on organic pasture nine months out of the year, rotating to fresh pasture every 24 hours. (They get organic hay in the winter.)
• Friends and family are welcome to take us out to dinner (or have us over for a meal)—as this might happen in real life—but if they expect us to pay our share at a restaurant, we'll tell them about our Food Stamp Challenge and invite them over for dinner at our house instead. While this may stretch our budget, it'd still be much cheaper than a night out at a Portland restaurant.
• We don't have a garden (yet) so we won't be supplementing our shopping with free veggies. Also, since we're not actually receiving SNAP benefits, we won't be eligible for the matching programs at local farmers' markets that I used three years ago. (Portland's program, which gives you $7 extra to spend for every $7 of SNAP benefits you spend at the farmers' market, has been so popular that they've had to reduce the matching amount from $10 to $7.)
organic beer will be too expensive for us
Can we do it? The jury is out. Don thinks it'll be fairly easy since we don't buy much processed food anyway and we're mostly vegetarian. But I have a feeling that we're going to have to sacrifice quite a bit—even considering we have some basic staples and spices already in the pantry. (We can say goodbye to beer, for instance, and we may have to cut back on organic condiments, which are astronomically priced in my opinion.) In the coming weeks, I'll share our struggles, favorite recipes, and shopping secrets.
You guys are great role models!! We should all be challenged to do this. You're making me aware of how much food I toss every day, especially because I know we have chickens. If you need a glass of wine or a cold beer in the next few weeks, stop in :)
Posted by: Charlotte Smith | 20 February 2013 at 05:48 PM
Ooooo...great challenge! I cannot wait to read the follow up post : ) You can help us figure out where we should prioritize our organic dollars!
Posted by: Kiné Fischler | 25 February 2013 at 06:13 PM
Hi, Neat post. There is a problem with your site in web explorer, may check this? IE still is the market chief and a huge component to people will pass over your excellent writing due to this problem.
Posted by: happywell.net | 15 September 2013 at 08:30 AM